Research
Articles
GARY REICH
University of Kansas
ALVAR AYALA MENDOZA
University of Michigan
'Educating Kids' Versus 'Coddling Criminals':
Framing the Debate over In-State Tuition for
Undocumented Students in Kansas
As more children of
undocumented workers graduate from U.S. high schools, many states are
considering laws to grant these students in-state tuition status. Kansas,
which adopted such a law in 2004, was an unlikely venue for this kind
of policy, considering the negative attitudes toward illegal immigrants
among the state's residents as well as its relatively small share of Hispanic
residents. We argue that the passage of Kansas's in-state tuition bill
occurred in large measure due to the skill of its proponents in framing
the issue as one of access to public education. We use a mix of qualitative
and quantitative data to show how proponents of the in-state tuition bill
were able to direct attention toward public education—an issue more
electorally palatable to legislators and their constituents—and
redirect attention away from immigration policy. The success of the bill
in Kansas has some applicability for similar legislation under consideration
in other states; however, as immigration policy has become more politically
charged, proponents of in-state tuition for undocumented students will
face renewed challenges in the legislative arena, as Kansas also demonstrates.
|
|